Chocolate Heart Thumbprint Cookies

Valentine's Day is almost here! And my feed has been blowing up with pink, purple, and red all over! And if you know me, then you know I'm not super into decorating or being overly festive for holidays. But, I LOVE Valentine's Day! I love that it's a holiday for absolutely no reason except to celebrate love. What is better than that?

I was looking for some organic Valentine's Day candy to buy for myself and the girls, and there's not a lot out there to be honest. But, I found these cute little chocolate hearts from Lake Champlain Chocolates. I bought all the flavors Amazon had Milk Chocolate, Dark Chocolate, and Dark Chocolate Raspberry. I thought these would be cute pushed into a thumbprint cookie, and I could also gift the girls some delicious chocolate hearts.

My thumbprints have been super popular on the blog recently, so I wanted to give you guys a Valentine's Day thumbprint cookie recipe. These cookies are just as easy as my Raspberry Thumbprints, so if you've baked those already then you got this! If you can't find the organic chocolate hearts, another option would be to place a piece of milk or dark chocolate in the middle and sprinkle India Tree Heart Sprinkles right on top so they bake in as the chocolate melts in the oven. And we do have these sprinkles in the bake shop, so stop by if you need some! Get the recipe below for my Chocolate Heart Thumbprint Cookies.

Tips for making the best Chocolate Heart Thumbprint Cookies

• Make sure your butter is soft. You should cream together the butter, sugar and vanilla before starting your timer. This means that you should mix these ingredients together until there are no chunks of butter. Then start the timer for and continue mixing.

• If you're using the Lake Champlain chocolate hearts, stick to dark chocolate hearts, not the milk chocolate. I originally tried this recipe with both, and the milk chocolate hearts burned in the oven. Milk chocolate can't be heated as high as dark chocolate, so this may have been why these hearts burned when I baked them. But, when chocolate burns it can get bubbly and weird looking and it doesn't taste good either! So stick with the dark chocolate.

• Make sure to refrigerate your cookie sheets. This helps the cookies hold their shape once baked. Thumbprints are a dense little cookie, so this is why refrigerating is an important step.

Chocolate Heart Thumbprint Cookies

Makes 30

2 sticks organic salted butter, softened

170 grams (3/4 cup) organic cane sugar

1 teaspoon organic vanilla extract

1 organic large egg

383 grams (3 cups) organic all purpose flour

30 organic dark chocolate hearts


Line 2 cookie sheets with parchment paper.

In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted the the paddle attachment, add the butte, cane sugar, and vanilla extract. Mix on low until combined, then set a timer for 5 minutes and mix until the mixture is light in color and fluffy.

Add the egg, and mix until combined. Add the flour, and mix on low until combined into a smooth dough.

Using your hands, form the dough into 30 balls and place on the prepared cookie sheets. Press a chocolate heart into the center of each cookie. Refrigerate the cookie sheets for 25 minutes.

Preheat the oven to 350°F.

Bake for 19 minutes, or until lightly browned on the bot­tom. Let cool completely on the cookie sheets.

Store in a cool dry place for up to 3 days.

Gluten Free - Replace the organic flour with 397 grams (2 1/2 cups plus 1 tablespoon) organic gluten free flour blend.

High Altitude - Bake at 350°F for 15 minutes, or until lightly browned on the bottom.

Did you make this recipe? Make sure to tag @dessertdorganic on Instagram!

  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Black RSS Icon

© 2021 Dessert'D Organic Bake Shop